<incom> FW: [TriumphOfContent] Google Offers a Map for Its Philanthropy (The NY Times)

[Michael Gurstein]

-----Original Message-----
From: TriumphOfContent at yahoogroups.com
[mailto:TriumphOfContent at yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Steven Brant
Sent: January 17, 2008 8:28 AM
To: steve at trimtabmanagementsystems.com
Subject: [TriumphOfContent] Google Offers a Map for Its Philanthropy (The NY
Times)


 From the article below...

DotOrg has focused on what it can do “uniquely,” said Sheryl  
Sandberg, vice president for global online sales and operations at  
Google, who, like all employees, is permitted to spend 20 percent of  
her time at the foundation or in other charitable ventures. “If you  
do things other people could do, you’re not adding value.”


http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/18/technology/18google.html

The New York Times

January 18, 2008

Google Offers a Map for Its Philanthropy

By HARRIET RUBIN

Google announced Thursday that it had come up with a plan that begins  
to fulfill the pledge it made to investors when it went public nearly  
four years ago to reserve 1 percent of its profit and equity to “make  
the world a better place.”

The philanthropy the company has set up — Google.org, or DotOrg as  
Googlers call it — will spend up to $175 million in its first round  
of grants and investments over the next three years, Google officials  
said. While it is like other companies’ foundations in making grants,  
it will also be untraditional in making for-profit investments,  
encouraging Google employees to participate directly and lobbying  
public officials for changes in policies, company officials said.

DotOrg officials said they had decided to spend the money on five  
initiatives: disease and disaster prevention; improving the flow of  
information to hold governments accountable in community services;  
helping small and medium-size enterprises; developing renewable  
energy sources that are cheaper than coal; and investing in the  
commercialization of plug-in vehicles.

Google may be one of America’s 10 richest corporations as measured by  
market value, but its budget for philanthropy is minuscule compared  
with the $70 billion of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

Still, Google’s founders, Sergey Brin and Larry Page, expressed a  
hope back in 2004 that “someday this institution may eclipse Google  
itself in terms of overall world impact.” What it lacks in size,  
though, Google.org may make up in cachet.

Larry Brilliant, a medical doctor who took on the role of director of  
Google.org 18 months ago, said he could not even begin to count how  
many spending proposals he had seen. “There are 6.5 billion people in  
the world,” Dr. Brilliant said in a recent interview, “and in the  
last 18 months I’ve met 6.4 billion, all of whom want, if not some of  
our money, then some of the Google pixie dust.”

Dr. Brilliant, who moved to an ashram in northern India in the 1970s  
and went on to play a major role in eradicating smallpox in the  
country, likened his moral quandary in figuring out how to spend  
Google.org’s money to that faced by a saint wandering the streets of  
Benares.

“There are 500 steps between the road and the Ganges,” he said. “On  
every step are beggars, lepers, people who have no arms or legs,  
people literally starving. The saint has a couple of rupees; how does  
a good and honorable person make a resource allocation decision? Do  
you weigh a hand that’s missing more than a leg? Someone who’s  
starving versus a sick child? In a much less dramatic way, that’s  
what the last 18 months have been for us.”

DotOrg has focused on what it can do “uniquely,” said Sheryl  
Sandberg, vice president for global online sales and operations at  
Google, who, like all employees, is permitted to spend 20 percent of  
her time at the foundation or in other charitable ventures. “If you  
do things other people could do, you’re not adding value.”

In contrast to DotOrg’s close tie to DotCom, employees of Microsoft  
have made Bill Gates wealthy but have no official influence in how  
the Gates Foundation money is spent.

The only urgency imposed on the foundation is how soon it can live up  
to the expectations. “Building a new ecosystem is not an overnight  
phenomenon,” Dr. Brilliant said. “Here at Google if you have a  
project, you press Send. We won’t work that quickly.”

But for all the enthusiasm for the new organization, there are  
critics. “It’s wonderful that this company is devoting massive  
resources to fixing big world problems, but they are taking an  
engineer’s perspective to them,” said Siva Vaidhyanathan, a cultural  
historian and media scholar at the University of Virginia. “Machines  
and software are not always the answer. Global problems arise from  
how humans have undervalued each other and miscommunicated with each  
other.”

He pointed to Google.org’s decision not to take a step like financing  
scholarships for girls in India who have not had access to education.  
“That’s what is so naïve about Google.org’s approach,” he said. “If  
you can educate a thousand girls in one state in India, you’ve  
already made a bigger difference than 99 percent of the human beings  
on earth because every one of those of girls can make a difference.”

The process of determining what to finance was not easy, said  
Jacquelline Fuller, the head of advocacy at Google.org. Beginning in  
the spring of 2007, “the 20 team members had 20 ideas.” Team members,  
she said, “debated, cried and held hands as we tried to determine  
what kind of difference we could make.” It took them almost a year to  
winnow down the list.Although it was just announcing its initiatives  
on Thursday, Google.org has already begun to give away some of its  
money.

That is the case with grants for the first of its initiatives — what  
the philanthropy calls “predict and prevent.” This effort focuses on  
strengthening early warning systems in countries around the world to  
detect a disease before it becomes pandemic, or a drought before it  
becomes a famine.

To attain that, DotOrg has made a grant of $5 million to a nonprofit  
group that Dr. Brilliant helped to set up, though it is independent  
from DotOrg. Called Instedd, for Innovative Support to Emergencies,  
Diseases and Disasters, the group seeks to improve data and  
communication networks. An additional $2.5 million has been awarded  
to the Global Health and Security Initiative to respond to biological  
threats in Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and China’s  
Yunnan Province.

“In recent years,” Dr. Brilliant said, “39 new communicable diseases  
with a potential to become pandemic have jumped species,” including  
SARS, or severe acute respiratory syndrome; monkey pox and bird flu.

“What if we could have been there when the H.I.V. moved from animal  
to chimp to human and could have averted that risk?” he asked. “To  
prevent or abort or slow a pandemic saves tens of millions of lives.”

The second initiative, called “the missing middle,” refers to the  
missing middle class in Africa and South Asia and the missing middle  
level of financing between microcredits and hedge funds.

Microcredit funds currently provide families with three or four or  
five days of livelihood, Dr. Brilliant said. “But what can you do  
when your kid is sick and you can’t work?” he said. “No country has  
ever emerged from poverty because of microcredit. Jobs make that  
possible. China did it with manufacturing, India did it with  
outsourced call centers.”

To that end, DotOrg has awarded $3 million to TechnoServe to find  
worthy entrepreneurs and help them build credit records and get  
access to larger markets.

The third initiative, “information for all,” is aimed at helping  
developing countries provide better government services by making  
information available on their efforts to improve health care, roads  
and electrification. “India has promised health care, work, and  
transparency throughout,” Dr. Brilliant said. “Yet it’s hard to do  
something like this on the scale that India is trying to do, to let  
people know what their entitlement is.”

DotOrg has awarded $2 million to support the Annual Status of  
Education report in India to assess the quality of education;  
$765,000 to create a Budget Information Service to improve district- 
level planning, and $660,000 to build communities of researchers and  
policy makers to deliver information.

DotOrg decided to finance literacy information because, said Lant  
Pritchett, a DotOrg adviser who teaches economic development at the  
Kennedy School of Government at Harvard, “We’re looking for things  
where Google could have a transformative impact. Ideas, flexibility,  
entrepreneurship are better than just cash on the table.”

Google.org’s fourth initiative supports the development of renewable  
energy sources that are cleaner and cheaper than coal. DotOrg has  
invested $10 million in eSolar, a company in Pasadena, Calif., that  
specializes in solar thermal power.

The philanthropy is also working to accelerate the commercialization  
of plug-in vehicles. Google, whose own computers and customers use  
plenty of energy, “does not want to be part of the problem; we want  
to be part of the solution,” Dr. Brilliant said.

“We’re not trying to bring returns to Google,” Dr. Brilliant said.  
“Profits are vital to businesses that will support the missions.”

Mark Dowie, author of the book “American Foundations,” said DotOrg is  
part of “a new mode of philanthropy that is very similar to venture  
capitalism, holding those they fund responsible in ways never seen  
before.” The danger, he said, “is that a lot of philanthropic work is  
not quantifiable. How do you qualify arts grant making, for example.”

Still, he added, “what would be worse is for Google not to give away  
its money, but to hoard it.”

Copyright 2008 The New York Times Company



 
Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/TriumphOfContent/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/TriumphOfContent/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    mailto:TriumphOfContent-digest at yahoogroups.com 
    mailto:TriumphOfContent-fullfeatured at yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    TriumphOfContent-unsubscribe at yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 


!DSPAM:2676,478f821b89021939577088!